Pussy Rioting
The nine lives of the Riot Grrrl Revolution
This week, we read a very interesting article
that was very different from the recent things that we have been reading
lately. Riot Grrrl was a movement to try
and bring awareness to some very important issues such as rape, domestic abuse,
women’s health, sexuality, and most importantly, female empowerment. Pussy Riot
was a band that we mainly focused on. There we approximately 11 women in total
in the group. In 2012, 5 of the members sang a song “Mother of God, put Putin
away!”. This song, by itself, was very offensive in my eyes. Religion is
something that is very important in my life and I took great offense to those
women singing that song in Cathedral in Moscow. I also did not like their style
of music either. Kind of screaming out words is not my type of music I like to
listen to. Putting on this performance actually put these women in jail for 2
years. I was very surprised to see how much action the police in Moscow took to
punish these women for singing. Personally I agree they the most definitely
should have gotten some type of punishment but 2 years in prison is quite
extreme.
After reading the lyrics to “Mother of
God, put Putin away!” and watching the music video, I had no respect for this
“band”. But then when we were introduced to their song “I Can’t Breathe” I was
actually very impressed. This song, unlike the other one, had the girl actually
singing in it, and their voices were actually pretty good. This song was in
dedication of a man in New York City who died from police blocking his airway
when trying to arrest him. He had told the policemen several times that he
could not breathe but nothing was done and he took his final breaths right
there. This song was very powerful and the music video was even more moving.
You could clearly see in the music video how hard they were struggling to
breathe which gave you a glimpse of what the man in New York was going through
when the police were on top of him. I also was shocked that this was Pussy
Riot’s first English song too.
Personally, I think Pussy Riot had good
intentions for their band but just sent their message the wrong was in Moscow.
There was no need to perform that type of song in such a sacred place. I think
they should stick to singing the same way they did for “I Can’t Breathe”. “I
Can’t Breathe” had such a powerful message that was carried out the right and
respectful way. Pussy Riot was definitely a band that I will remember learning about.
I really enjoy this post, Nicole! It is very similar to my my post and opinions. As a Christian, I was extremely offended and upset by their lyrics and choice of venue for their protest. They should not stomp on other people's beliefs when they are complaining about people stomping on theirs! I also agree that they sounded horrible in Russian. Granted, the song was more yelling than singing, but they just sounded immature and stupid. When they sang "I Can't Breathe" they sang in english and sounded ten times better. That song had a stronger impact on me and it wasn't offensive! Great job Nicole.
ReplyDeleteI really like your post. I also found the Cathedral performance very disrespectful, but thought their I Cant Breathe song was more powerful, and got the message across so much better than acting out and disrupting peoples time with God.
ReplyDelete