This blog represents the work of Bridgewater State University students. This course is focused not only on women in the music industry, but women who use/used their voices to comment on social and political issues. We are focused on how women have used/use their voices in order to express their power as women. We will analyze their work mainly through an intersectional feminist lens. This blog will contain the students' responses to weekly readings and classroom discussions.
Friday, February 26, 2016
Patti Smith
Patti Smith is such an influential person in the Punk Rock Scene. During the 60's she impacted that genre of music because as usual the men in the music industry were the one that had huge success around those Time. If a person is listening to her song such as " people have the power" it's clear she is more of a poet. The way she sings her song it's as if she is performing at an open mic.Her songs are very neutral and usually, talk about how we can change the world to make it a better place. She can be seen as a sort of activist. I find interesting that around the time she starting performing that she doesn't like to be identified as a woman but as an "artist.She believes in gender fluidity which is not an a bad thing. I'm sure many women who express the same beliefs as her. She was inspired to be a certain way. Out of all the individuals, we learned about so far in class Patti Smith is the least likable to me. In her interview with Frickle David, she mentioned how in high school most of her friends were black"My world was so small I didn't even know there was a civil right"This is very confusing because if she had African American friends I'm sure she overheard stories of inequalities and such. Although Patti Smith's poem are about a making positive change in the world I feel like there are a lot of issues such as racial, gender inequality that she is oblivious too. Patti Smith mentioned how "I grew up not believing in an enemy" This may explain why she opposed to feminist and is oblivious to important movement such as the civil rights movement.I believe she led a privileged childhood. She could have made a better impact if she supported the feminist movement back in the 60s.She could have paved the way for much more women. In comparison to Nina Simmon Patti smith was not a feminist and did not discuss social injustice as much she was neutral regarding several issues while Nina Simmons it was clear she was a feminist fighting for women's power and her whole career focused on indirect protesting to social injustice
Pussy Rioting
The nine lives of the Riot Grrrl Revolution
This week, we read a very interesting article
that was very different from the recent things that we have been reading
lately. Riot Grrrl was a movement to try
and bring awareness to some very important issues such as rape, domestic abuse,
women’s health, sexuality, and most importantly, female empowerment. Pussy Riot
was a band that we mainly focused on. There we approximately 11 women in total
in the group. In 2012, 5 of the members sang a song “Mother of God, put Putin
away!”. This song, by itself, was very offensive in my eyes. Religion is
something that is very important in my life and I took great offense to those
women singing that song in Cathedral in Moscow. I also did not like their style
of music either. Kind of screaming out words is not my type of music I like to
listen to. Putting on this performance actually put these women in jail for 2
years. I was very surprised to see how much action the police in Moscow took to
punish these women for singing. Personally I agree they the most definitely
should have gotten some type of punishment but 2 years in prison is quite
extreme.
After reading the lyrics to “Mother of
God, put Putin away!” and watching the music video, I had no respect for this
“band”. But then when we were introduced to their song “I Can’t Breathe” I was
actually very impressed. This song, unlike the other one, had the girl actually
singing in it, and their voices were actually pretty good. This song was in
dedication of a man in New York City who died from police blocking his airway
when trying to arrest him. He had told the policemen several times that he
could not breathe but nothing was done and he took his final breaths right
there. This song was very powerful and the music video was even more moving.
You could clearly see in the music video how hard they were struggling to
breathe which gave you a glimpse of what the man in New York was going through
when the police were on top of him. I also was shocked that this was Pussy
Riot’s first English song too.
Personally, I think Pussy Riot had good
intentions for their band but just sent their message the wrong was in Moscow.
There was no need to perform that type of song in such a sacred place. I think
they should stick to singing the same way they did for “I Can’t Breathe”. “I
Can’t Breathe” had such a powerful message that was carried out the right and
respectful way. Pussy Riot was definitely a band that I will remember learning about.
Pussy Riot-Tackling Controversial Issues
In Wednesdays class, we had a discussion about the Riot Grrrl Movement. It was a movement that combined punk music with feminism and politics. Part of our discussion revolved around the Russian punk band, Pussy Riot. They were a group of women ranging in ages 20-33. We watched their performance of "Mother of God, Drive Putin Away” which was the song that led to 3 of the band members arrest and ultimately, two years of incarceration. The song was performed in a Cathedral in Moscow, Russia and the lyrics were very intense. I understand that they wanted to get their point across, however, to perform it in a church where people worship God, was very inconsiderate and upsetting. As a Christian, I feel as though there are plenty of other ways to get your point across. They, as women, feel that their rights are trampled upon, and that sexism is wrong and I’m not saying that I disagree, however, they are trampling on others rights and basically doing the same things that they don't want done to them.
An example of a project that I support them in doing, is the song “I Can’t Breathe” which was written in memory of Eric Garner who was killed by police in New York City in 2014. The song and music video display an accurate depiction of his story and what it is like to be suffocated. I think this song and the music video did a fantastic job of getting his story out there and making bold statement. They didn't have to swear or say offensive things like they did in the cathedral, but their lyrics were still taken very seriously. In my opinion, “I Can’t Breathe” was ten times more powerful than their performance of “Mother of God, Drive Putin Away.” I am in no way against punk music or feminism, however I think it all goes back to the golden rule: treat others the way you want to be treated. There is no use fighting fire with fire, but I am not sure this world will ever come to that realization.
Thursday, February 25, 2016
Riot Grrrl Movement Response
The Riot Grrrl Movement started in the spring of 1991 when members of the all, girl punk band, Bratsmobile, and Kathleen Hanna of Bikini Kill started organizing weekly meetings that they called Riot Grrrl. "In their attempt to realize a feminist politics of everyday life, the members of Riot Grrrl sought to construct an organic, non-hierarchical community that was responsive to the subjective needs of its participants" (319). They left the definition of Riot Grrrl opened, members of the movement stated, "We want the definition of Riot Grrrl to be whatever anyone who wants to use the term wants it to be. We feel that over-organization would cost us the individuality we spend too much of the time fighting the rest of the world for" (319). They brought important issues to the surface including, "sexual identity, self-preservation, racism awareness, surviving, and sexual abuse" (319). One of the things that stood out to me the most was when they wrong "bitch" and "slut" over their bodies at a concert. It was so powerful. I think their mindset was intended to draw attention to publicize issues like sexual abuse and rape that were largely ignored by the media. I think what they did was very moving, and overlooked. But at times I think they went a little over the top. We discussed in class, and watched a video of the protests that they did in front of a church in Russia. I found it incredibly disrespectful. I completely understand they wanted to raise awareness of the on-going issue, and good for them for being so bold about it, but if anything, I feel like it made them look childish. It gives people the wrong impression.
Riot Grrrl Movement
“Riot Grrrl DC held a national convention, which brought girls
from all over the country together to discuss issues central to the movement at
the time: sexual identity, self-preservation, racism awareness, surviving
sexual abuse and whether Riot Grrrls fit or don’t fit into the punk com-
munity”. Riot Grrrl movement , is a feminist punk movement which is all about
women rights and equality. “With this whole Riot Grrrl thing, we are not trying
to make money or get famous; we’re trying to do something important, to network
with grrrls all over, to make changes in our lives and the lives of other
grrrls”. While reading this article, both of these quotes stood out to me the
most because it really explains and give many details of what the Riot Grrrls
movement is about. The goal of the riot girrrls was to raise awareness, which I
believe they did even though there are still issues associated with feminism
today. During class, we had watched a video on the Russian Riot Girrrl protest,
which made me feel uncomfortable, and found it disrespectful. Even though I
support that they were trying to raise awareness, I do not think a church was a
good place to protest.
Not a Rock and Roll nigger response
Kyla Hullum
Professor Santos
25 February 2016
Not
a Rock and Roll nigger response
I
honestly found this reading to be very potent, and daring. I like that Orlandersmith
starts off the story how she first got into rock and roll music, and the genre’s
she grew up around that were the complete opposite of it. It’s very rare that
you see black individuals, especially women who are into rock and roll and
punk, so I thought it was fascinating to hear what she saw in the music and how
it made her feel.
One
thing that stood out to me was Orlandersmith reaction to Pattie Smith at a
music festival when she came onstage and started to repeat the word “Nigger”
and the crowd filled with white people started chanting “I’m a nigger, a rock
and roll nigger.” The way her and the other two black teens looked at each
other and just stood in silence stated how they felt about what she just said,
because she used a word to name everyone, a word that has been used to put down
blacks. There looks at each other stated enough that what she was saying was
messed up and how the crowd just followed along with her as if it was never a racist
term. I see why Orlandersmith was debating whether or not to keep supporting
her because the word “Nigger” should not be used by any white person to be
turned into a positive phrase to represent outsiders.
I
understand why Orlandersmith tried to use the term into something positive
because she can relate to being an outcast from white society, just like black
people. On the other hand, I don’t think she had a right to use that word at
all because it’s been used as the ultimate put down word for blacks, and has a
negative vibe to it that you can never turn that word into something confident.
I have respect for Pattie Smith for trying to make a change, but using the word
“Nigger” was not the proper way to go about it because not everybody is going
to easily support her, especially blacks in my opinion.
Another
part that stood out to me was on page 139, when Orlandersmith described the
encounter she had with Pattie Smith on the street, and how she confronted her
about the song saying, “I like your work…But I have problems with the song rock
and roll nigger.” I kind of laughed internally. My reason is because of the way
Pattie Smith than told her to have a nice day and walked away but then kept
looking back at her as if she made her rethink if it was a good idea to write
that song.
I
can also relate to how rock and roll music opened Orlandersmith’s eyes to a
scene where she felt like she fit in because that is how I felt when I first listened
to Soca music. I grew up around reggae, but didn’t really start listening to Soca
until middle school and I feel like that changed my view on music a lot because
it gave me energetic sensation in a way and had lots of good vibes. When I listen
to Soca music it feels as if it is taking me to another place where I can
express myself by dancing to it, just like when Orlandersmith goes to Rock
concerts, she feels like it is where she belongs.
In
all, I think it was a really good article because she expressed what it was
like growing up as a black rock and roll lover and how her views of it almost
changed because of one song that had a racial slur in it.
Monday, February 22, 2016
The lyrics of Beyoncé’s
song Formation hold very political meanings behind them. This political influence has created controversy
all over the world. Beyoncé presents her love for black pride through this
song. The chorus “I like my baby heir
with baby hair and afros, I like my negro nose with Jackson Five Nostrils”
shows how she is proud of and not ashamed of her culture. I believe that in the video for this song, Beyoncé
includes her daughter with her hair in afro to stand up against the people who
shunned her for keeping her daughter’s hair in that way. It is a statement to say that black woman are
beautiful naturally as they are. In the music video it explores black culture
by taking place in New Orleans and having a little boy dancing in front of cops,
which elutes to Trevon Martin. The part
of the music video when the boy stands before cops and the words “Stop shooting
us” really stood out to me.
Choosing to put that
scene in the music video was a very political decision on Beyoncé’s part. I can see how people may think that is disrespectful
towards cops but in this scene I believe that she is trying to gain sympathy
for her cause by using a youthful figure pleading for his life. It was also a
huge political statement for Beyoncé to place herself on a cop car sinking
under water.
Also in this song Beyoncé displays her strong sense of girl
power. “I slay” represents that woman
that need to go out and take what’s theirs, and need to get the job done. The lyrics “Okay, ladies, now let’s get in
formation” is a call out to all the woman of the world to come together and
take the roles necessary to gain equal gender rights. In the song she mentions that she’ll take her
man to Reb Lobster, take him on her flight chopper, take him to the mall, and
get his song played on the radio station. Those lyrics represent that she doesn’t
need a man to support her that she makes her own way and can actually support
him. I love that she takes dominance in this song
over a male figure.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)